I’ve been quite frustrated with my rating system lately. It did not give me the freedom to really rate the books I read. I know that probably does not make sense to anyone but me. I broke up the A’s and B’s because I feel as if those two need some clarification. A book can either be a high 5 or a low 5 but just rating it a 5 doesn’t express that. I didn’t do that for anything below the C’s because I don’t think it’s necessary.
A+-Excellent. Borderline classic. Must read. Would recommend to anyone with a pulse. There won’t be many of these. This will stay in my library right next to Pride and Prejudice. Current ratings-5*
A-Excellent but still has some minor issues. Must read. I will keep a copy in my shelves and will make it a point to read it again. Current Ratings-5 stars (I will access where it will go)
A- -Still excellent but has some more distinct issues. Must read. I will keep a copy in my library and read it again someday. Current Ratings-5 stars (I will access where it will go)
B+-Very good. I liked it. Well worth a read. Very close to a A rating but not quite there. Someone else might like it a bit more but I will still keep a copy in my library. Current Rating-4.75
B-Very good. Some minor flaws but nothing to cry about. I’ll keep a copy in my collection. Worth a read. Current Rating-4.5 stars
B- -Still very good. Has some flaws but a good read nonetheless. Current rating-4 stars
C+-Didn’t make the B’s but was still good. There were too many issues for me to be able to give it a B but still worthwhile. Current Rating-3.75
C-It was okay. Not really my type of thing but someone else might like it more. Current rating 3.5 stars
C- -It was okay could have been a lot better. It is a good bit away from being put in my donation pile. Current rating-3 stars
D-If you are really desperate for something to read and this is the only book around. Current Rating-2 stars.
F-Don’t bother. I don’t like being mean but this book was terrible. I mean terrible. Current Rating-1 star
Filed under: random | Tagged: new rating system




RSS - Posts

Came to your blog from 20 in 2009.
Very nice blog, enjoyed going through the selection of books you have read this year…
I also like your rating system. I also struggle to rate books, and oftentimes I don’t think I do a good job with it.
Primarily, because I have just ratings just 1-5, and it is difficult because most books fall in the 3-4 rating, and it doesn’t make sense when I rate all books the same…
Anyway, will try to implement something different with my system.
If you are interested, you can read my book reviews at: http://nishitak.wordpress.com/shhh-i-am-reading/
I’m glad you like it. I thought the 5 star thing was limiting me a bit. I found most books were ending up in the 4 or 5 scale when they should have been lower but not necessarily a 3. I’m liking the new rating so far. Gives me some wiggle room.
I will definitely check out your blog!